New Book Summary: The Lessons of History by Will and Ariel Durant


The Lessons of History by Will and Ariel Durant is a sweeping examination of history, human nature, and the patterns that we can see when we adopt a long-term perspective. My latest book summary looks at the lessons we might glean from the past.

As usual, the key takeaways are below, and you can find the full summary by clicking the link above.

KEY TAKEAWAYS

  • Natural forces play a key role in shaping history:
    • Geology and climate limit us, but less so as technology grows.
    • Natural selection requires competition, quantity, and diversity.
  • Morals and religion maintain social order:
    • Moral codes are universal and necessary, but change over time according the context. Values that made sense during an agricultural era evolved after the Industrial Revolution.
    • Religion was borne out of fear — the link to morality came afterwards, and strengthened the role of religion.
    • Religion and morals play a bigger role in maintaining social order when laws are weaker, and vice versa.
  • Economic forces throughout history:
    • Though leaders may have appealed to non-economic matters (e.g. religion and nationalism) to motivate the masses, the hidden, underlying motive for war was often economic.
    • Inequality is natural and inevitable, because men are born with different abilities. The only way to constrain inequality is to constrain freedom — but doing so will make a society more vulnerable to external threats.
    • Redistribution occasionally breaks up concentrations of wealth. Peaceful redistributions redistribute wealth whereas violent ones just redistribute poverty.
    • Past examples of socialism failed as government bureaucracies grew too large (and corrupt), and required increasingly high taxes to fund them.
    • The authors believe socialism and capitalism will keep moving closer and eventually converge.
  • Government and power
    • Minority rule is natural, because centralised power is more effective than diluted power.
    • Democracy is historically rare and difficult to sustain. However, it has done more good than any other form of government.
  • War is a constant. Peace is unstable and maintained only by a balance or acknowledged supremacy of power.
  • Progress and decay in human history:
    • Human nature is slow to change: This is why history repeats itself, though not exactly.
    • There has been progress, as defined by the average person’s ability to control the conditions of their life, rather than by “happiness”.
    • However, progress is neither continuous nor universal. There will be setbacks along the way.
    • Decay is natural, but it gives new civilisations an opportunity to rise. And civilisations never truly die, anyway — they live on through memories and records.

Thanks for subscribing!

Until next time,

To Summarise

ToSummarise.com

I summarise non-fiction books with more detail and critical analysis than you'll find elsewhere. Join my newsletter to get new summaries delivered straight to your inbox!

Read more from ToSummarise.com

I'm back! I took July and August off because of a move, but this month I managed to get out 1 book summary and 2 blog posts: Book summaries How Asia Works by Joe Studwell (30 mins) — argues that the East Asian economies of Japan, Korea, Taiwan and China became developmental success stories with a 3-part formula involving agriculture, manufacturing, and the financial system. Blog posts How Asia Works with causal diagrams (5 mins) — tries to distil Joe Studwell's theory into a diagram. How AI...

After a long hiatus, I'm back with a shiny new book summary for How Asia Works: Success and Failure in the World's Most Dynamic Region by Joe Studwell. Though published in 2014, it holds up pretty well, with some of its insights on industrial policy and central bank independence might be more relevant than ever (though one must take care not to overgeneralise from things that worked in a particular context in the past). Anyway, as usual the key takeaways are below, and you can find the full...

Hope you've all had a good June. I've only posted 1 book summary and 2 blog posts: Book summaries Deep Utopia by Nick Bostrom (22 mins) — this weird book explores the question of what utopia could look like and what problems might be left after we've reached a state of technological maturity. Blog posts — both posts this month came about as I've been thinking and reading about the economics of AI. I'm planning to do a third post that will address that more directly, but these two lay the...